We recently discovered that the distillation still used to distill Kashmiri rose oil analyzed in our report* had processed geranium oil before distilling the rose oil. Unfortunately, the still was not thoroughly cleaned and the reported presence of isomenthone, geranyl formate, citronellyl formate and 10-epi-eudesmol in Kashmir rose oil came from contamination of geranium oil.
We regret this error.
R.P. Adams and A.S. Shawl
*“Rose Oil in Kashmiri India,” P&F magazine, volume 34, April 2009, page 22.